![]() |
| image copied from bookshop.org |
As we head into the holiday season and December, I thought that I'd discuss a Jane Austen manuscript fragment that has been continued by author Claudia Gray. It seemed a timely moment for it, because we will be coming up on the anniversary of Austen's birth in December and a new film adaptation of one of the author's beloved published works, Sense and Sensibility, is currently out in theaters.
I knew that in addition to her six published novels, Jane Austen had left an unfinished manuscript, Lady Susan. I also was familiar with the TV series on PBS, Sanditon, that is an adaptation of an incomplete work she left behind as well. I was not familiar with any other manuscript fragments, however. Not until I learned of Claudia Gray's continuation of The Watsons. This manuscript fragment, according to Gray's author's note, had the first four chapters drafted out by Austen, and they were also partially revised by her before being set aside and never finished. Gray did extensive research before continuing the rest of the story. In her author's note she gave considerable explanation for the few changes she made to some characters in terms of their names, where she chose to have the story set, and a few other minor changes. I would agree in reading those first four chapters, which Gray tried to keep relatively untouched from what Austen originally wrote, that this work was different from Austen's other published works and less polished in form.
However, I did enjoy the departure that this story takes from Austen's other popular works such as Pride and Prejudice or Sense and Sensibility, which both have a Cinderella quality to them. A gentile but impoverished young woman of wit and spirit gets saved from destitution and a loveless marriage of convenience by a wealthy man who truly has a heart of gold and was just sadly misunderstood at the beginning of the story. Don't get me wrong, I love both of these novels and their happy ends. But if you go into The Watsons expecting this same formula to be applied, you might be surprised.
Rather than Ada being swept up by the wealthy nobleman, Lord Osborne, who becomes fascinated with her at the beginning of the story, she is instead more impressed by his poorer counterpart, Mr. Howard, the local vicar who lives in the parsonage with his recently widowed sister and her children. Furthermore, rather than Lord Osborne simply being misunderstood and secretly having a heart of gold, he is instead as cool and out of touch as he at first appears. However, Gray does give Lord Osborne some redemption and growth later in the novel.
The reason for Ada's impoverishment is also slightly different and more heartbreaking. Ada was taken in by her aunt and uncle who were well off and raised by them like a daughter. But after her uncle dies and her aunt remarries, Ada is not only disinherited of the dowry she was promised, her aunt informs her by letter that she is not returning to their home, but instead moving to Ireland with her new spouse and that Ada will be expected to return to her own family. A family where she has three unmarried sisters and an ailing father. While this is reminiscent to Austen's other novels as well, Ada's reaction to her change in circumstances and her aunt's callous behavior is internalized much more sharply and while outwardly she appears sanguine about it, she is decidedly not. In fact, she does not accept what her aunt did to her at all. But feels she must pretend to in order to move on with her life. Another noticeable departure in how this all transpires is that Ada's change in circumstance all happens off page before the novel even begins, rather than unfolding at the start as it does for the Dashwood sisters at the beginning of Sense and Sensibility.
The love triangle and tension all of these things create from just these first few chapters leaves plenty of fodder for Claudia Gray to turn into a full length story. Something that I think Gray accomplishes well. I found myself easily liking Ada and rooting for her. Some of the other characters I did not enjoy as much. Clear parallels could be drawn between two of Ada's older sisters, Judith and Phoebe and the oldest Bennett sisters. But whereas Lizzy is witty but still kind, Phoebe is witty, pragmatic, but meaner spirited and Judith while selfless like Jane, is a much poorer judge of character and self-deluded.
As the romantic tension plays out and Ada is forced to decide whether to marry well to save her family or follow her heart, the ways that Gray portrays the class differences in an unequal match are well drawn and more realistic than most fictional Austen adaptations tend to be. I found myself wondering if Jane Austen herself would have taken a similar path with her characters if she'd lived long enough to continue the story.
All in all, The Watsons gave me much to consider and think about as I read. I enjoyed the story overall, though I cannot say I loved it as much as Pride and Prejudice or Persuasion, my two favorites among Austen's complete published works. But I did enjoy this departure that Austen seemed to be making from her previous stories and that Gray continued, adding some of her own literary license and flair along the way. And do not fret dear readers, all ends happily for Ada and most of her family, as Miss Austen would have surely intended for it to.
As for what I will review next, I may have to take a short break from my monthly blog reviews in December as I am in the thick of edits for my own upcoming published work. But I still plan to email out my author newsletter for December and will share what I've been reading briefly in it. If you'd like to subscribe to that, please check out my website to do so at https://www.annschwarz.com/.

No comments:
Post a Comment