 |
| image copied from Goodreads |
I'm admittedly behind the times by a wide margin on the Mercy Thompson series as the first novel came out in 2006. However, to be fair at that time the market was flooded with many popular urban fantasy series, riding the wave of
Dresden Files fame and the likes of YA sagas like
Twilight and Cassandra Clare's
Mortal Instruments. So, it was hard to keep up. But I recently found graphic novel adaptations of the first few books in the series and decided when my sister recommended it, and loaned me the first book, (Thanks, Megan!) that now was a good time to give this urban fantasy a try. I'm glad I did and for this review, I'm going to discuss the first book and the graphic novel adaptation of it. I thought it'd be fun to read one and then follow up with reading the other.
So, what I can say about the novel right off the bat is that it has held up very well over time. As I was reading it, I didn't feel that it was twenty years outdated at all. In fact, in terms of the worldbuilding I would say that Patricia Briggs was thinking ahead by bringing up how much harder it was becoming to keep the supernatural and magical world under wraps with advancing technology and forensic science. That isn't something that I think was always addressed in urban fantasy back then. Or it was handled in a way that explained how some magic users could still keep humans in the dark by making technology glitchy around them, like Butcher does with his Harry Dresden. However, in Briggs's world the Gray Lords over the fae have already revealed themselves to humanity and as a result, many of the lesser fae, at least, have been forced to live on reservations. Another thing that I liked about this series is the diversity of the main character and the portrayal of her as a walker, someone who can magically shift into a coyote. Many walkers or skinwalkers then and now, have been negatively stereotyped as cannibals or monsters and villains in fantasies and urban fantasies over the years. But Briggs offers us a different perspective that is more respectful, in my opinion, of Native American folklore and culture by making Mercy's ability more in keeping with the natural world and less an evil monstrosity. In fact, I would say that from Mercy's point of view, the European werewolves and vampires are more monstrous and predatory in an unnatural sense than any walker that might still exist.
Another positive that I feel has stood up to time over the last several years is the characterization of Mercy herself. Briggs gave her a profession that makes her a minority in the human world in the same way she is in the supernatural one, as a auto mechanic. Still today there are fewer women working in this field than there probably should be. Mercy is independent and like many urban fantasy characters has already endured much tragedy and loss in her life. But while she is content to be largely a loner, she isn't cynical of closed off. Mercy does have contact with her family and has developed some friendships with some powerful beings. She also lives next door to the werewolf alpha for her region. I don't think it is too much of a spoiler to say that I'm pretty sure Adam, her werewolf neighbor, is going to be an important future love interest for Mercy later in the series. Despite his obvious charisma and dangerous appeal though, Mercy is clear on setting her boundaries as far as what she'll tolerate from him and his natural machismo. I liked that about her. She claims to be rash and impatient and in some instances she is, but I never felt that her decisions as she becomes more and more enmeshed in what is going on with the werewolves in the mystery of the story were out of character or just plain dumb. I also felt that the rest of the cast of characters were given complexity and reasonable motivations for why they do the things that they do. So, I really enjoyed this first installment in the series and will continue to read more.
 |
| image copied from Goodreads |
As for the graphic novel adaptation, I was a little taken aback by where it starts. Instead of opening with Mercy and the boy who comes to her looking for work, as the novel does, we get some backstory about the wider world by finding out that the fae have revealed themselves to humans. In looking at this though from an adaptation standpoint, it made sense after I continued reading. It sets up the world right away and helps it stand out from other urban fantasies at the same time and eliminates the need for too much dialogue or monologue for Mercy as a character once we switch to her. The adapter, David Lawrence, made good choices in giving us some visual backstory for the world, then giving us the first gripping action scene with Mercy and Mac, the boy she's helped, then takes us back a few days before to when Mac first shows up in Mercy's shop. I thought that arranging the story and visuals in this way gave us some important worldbuilding, drew us into the story and action right away and then allowed us to take a step back and say, okay, here's how this all transpired in the first place. In terms of the illustrations and artwork, Amelia Woo also did an amazing job. I was not disappointed by any of her depictions of the characters from the novel. Based on the descriptions of them from the book I think her artwork was spot on and adds to the visual narration of the story in the graphic novel.
So, if you're an urban fantasy fan and you've never given the Mercy Thompson series a read, I highly recommend it. I also found it very entertaining to read the first book and then follow up by reading the first graphic novel adaptation right afterwards while the story was still fresh in my mind. Both were available through my local library system, so if you have a library card with your own public library, they shouldn't be hard to find. I checked out the graphic novel on my library's digital hoopla app.
For my next reads and reviews for April, I'm considering either a cozy mystery by one of my Rowan Prose pub siblings, or one of the paranormal suspenses that I bought from Plenty Bookshop when I went to their Wine and Words Festival the beginning of March. As always, I came away from that with far more books than I probably should have. Stay tuned for my next review in mid-April!